|
 
- 積分
- 7798
- 貢獻
- 1182
- 參與
- 6616
|
本帖最後由 boy4dudes 於 2017-5-24 01:46 編輯
我的意思是: 最佳XXX 獎項適用於流行曲嗎?
michaelycy_2007 發表於 2017-5-23 23:35 
As I said before, 流行曲應不應該有優劣之分 (優劣 as you put it) and 應不應該有最佳XXX獎項, 這是一個非常個人的 value judgement. 我個人認為有好過無.
當然, 技術上一定可行, 不過這樣的獎項有意義嗎? 你製作首歌, 目的係流行, 不過偏偏要被評質素
michaelycy_2007 發表於 2017-5-23 23:35
年度最佳技術, 製作等提名及獎項有一定意義 - apart from the singer, a song is a 精神, 時間, 靈魂, 心血 of many people. While singers usually get all the glory, musicians, composers, lyricists, producers, sound engineers, etc, deserve recognition. 提名及獎項 (如果評審盡力做得公平認真), 提名及獎項是對音樂人一種尊敬及鼓勵.
製作首歌, 目的係流行, it's true for big record companies because they want hit songs and profit, after all, they are running a business.
被評質素 is an Artist's Curse: you create a song, an artwork, a poem, a movie and you put it out there, you WILL be judged. Unless you keep it to yourself forever, no one knows about it, then no one will judge you.
From an artist's perspective, 你製作首歌, 目的係流行, it's not true for every artist. There are many many artists in the world who produce non-mainstream music, artwork, indie movies, not because they want their product to become 流行, it's because having ideas and creating these into whatever forms is in their blood, in their nature, an urge, or they want to express a message, an idea, an opinion, like TV and film documentaries. 如果你製作首歌, 目的只係為流行, why do so many indie artists make alternative music that are not K songs?
如果一首流行曲, 好多音樂人欣賞, 不過大眾完全不懂欣賞, 咁佢叫成功嗎? 我覺得好失敗
michaelycy_2007 發表於 2017-5-23 23:35
You are entitled to your opinions on this one. However, as I mentioned, 什麼是流行於大眾的歌曲真係很難一貫定義, 什麼是大眾? Kingjer's definition of 大眾 and Donald Trump's definition of 大眾 could be really different, especially in this era of fake news and alternative facts.
Goodnight 
|
|
發表於 2017-5-21 11:19
| 
