maksiuhong

百姓咁高質大碟都祗能取得171位, 祗能說CM會員都是以貌取人多過真心評論大碟 ...
hkwilliamsiu 發表於 2020-5-12 18:13

做咩曲線吹奏心姐

bagfgfcde

Serrini ig share 咗第三位個po !

on07111

我都無投票
hkwilliamsiu 發表於 2020-5-12 18:10

以為你棄暗投明，大義滅親唔投坤坤投第二個

doughnut

Yuki有65都算係咁，但點解誰的青春不迷惘冇入圍

616.1314

百姓咁高質大碟都祗能取得171位, 祗能說CM會員都是以貌取人多過真心評論大碟 ...
hkwilliamsiu 發表於 2020-5-12 18:13

你點解唔投
坤坤對你好失望

hkwilliamsiu

百姓咁高質大碟都祗能取得171位, 祗能說CM會員都是以貌取人多過真心評論大碟

hkwilliamsiu

坤坤點解零分，唔係有個鐵粉咩
on07111 發表於 2020-5-10 22:20

我都無投票

powerful

mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:15

如果你睇埋樂評選，會發現年度專輯全部入晒20大，係得Evil is a point of view 五十名外

洗衣王國130

啲初稿好正
不過都仲係河蟹咗我串 the album 嗰句嘢 他
616.1314 發表於 2020-5-11 23:48

    即刻寫返出嚟啦
     好喜歡你話 人妻的偽術 有 弦外之音 我有同感

616.1314

啲初稿好正
不過都仲係河蟹咗我串 the album 嗰句嘢 他

bagfgfcde

若未忘未棄 就拾回原稿

JasOh103

好似黃偉文咁有初稿睇

ed8671ed

二零一零年代精選五十唱片

感謝幫忙撰文的每位，由於字數限制關係，部分篇幅較長的文章會有所縮減，以下為各位提交介紹文的原稿：
https://drive.google.com/open?id=1FjDEzBt3R9T-FYQSKxM1SifR_Qs-IlHoZ0pu7UmRXgk

ed8671ed

post #3 已 update

帥小寶`

我印象中12年已經好多人插佢
Someday I'll Fly同WHUD五分都唔算多仲插佢隻隻碟都係外國demo廣東 ...
JayantL 發表於 2020-5-11 20:32

   邊諗到08年男女新人而加紅到咁

maksiuhong

我印象中12年已經好多人插佢
Someday I'll Fly同WHUD五分都唔算多仲插佢隻隻碟都係外國demo廣東 ...
JayantL 發表於 2020-5-11 20:32

咩吖 咪就係拍片話人唔be true to yourself 開始先插得勁
之前只係因為唔着重香港市場 同K歌有些少一式一樣先串佢

Where did you go what have you done
hookline 最好填英文

JayantL

其實佢2013/14年變強國歌手之前
CM都算幾buy佢
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-11 20:02

我印象中12年已經好多人插佢
Someday I'll Fly同WHUD五分都唔算多仲插佢隻隻碟都係外國demo廣東歌+一大堆國語

帥小寶`

巧豬超額完成 !! 恭喜 !!
掛住我地既樂壇超級區議會 琪琪

帥小寶`

171        百姓        吳業坤  2016        0

笑到我

mosesming

對Xposed爭少少入50大感到驚訝
睇嚟大家對阿漿都仲有留戀
foreverkontinue 發表於 2020-5-11 19:49

    其實佢2013/14年變強國歌手之前
CM都算幾buy佢

foreverkontinue

對Xposed爭少少入50大感到驚訝
睇嚟大家對阿漿都仲有留戀

mosesming

個list好yum
又西又水又熱咁
hehehaha 發表於 2020-5-11 18:57

連袋伯大吮

hehehaha

關於搞唔搞00-09年百大
不如我拋個磚分享下我嘅十大
大家諗下自己嘅十大又係點？
諗諗下大家就可能會想搞{: ...
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-11 08:21

個list好yum
又西又水又熱咁

hehe

Top 10 for me:

1. 火鳥 - 楊千嬅
2. 生於斯 - C AllStar
3. 接近天空的地方 - 泳兒
4. Escape - 陳柏宇
5. [dal segno] - Supper Moment
6. Sail Away - Robynn & Kendy
7. Twisted - Kolor
8. Live A Life - 周國賢
9. The Fifth Season - 胡琳
10. My January - 吳雨霏

No My January wanna cry

harry

極係一隻好難推嘅碟
連streaming都冇
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:40

A組投左極
1. Cantopopsibility - C AllStar
2. Connected - RubberBand
3. Kontinue - 謝安琪
4. Live A Life - 周國賢
5. 流行反撃戰 - MastaMic
6. 蓋亞 - 林憶蓮
7. 極 - 鍾氏兄弟
8. 本原 - 陳健安
9. ...3mm - 陳奕迅
10. 15 - 方大同

以為masta mic都會入一隻點知...
不過好開心Live A Life 第二個分數拋離咁多

JasOh103

唔同意搞00-09因為個篩選已經大不同
00-02冇咗堆種子歌曲 呢個位已經係bias

不了

mosesming

關於搞唔搞00-09年百大
不如我拋個磚分享下我嘅十大
大家諗下自己嘅十大又係點？
諗諗下大家就可能會想搞

1. 下一站天國
2. 鍾無艷
3. 地盡頭
4. 弱水三千
5. The Best Is Yet to Come
6. 化蝶
7. 露西
8. 大熱
9. 不如不見
10. 三千年後

bagfgfcde

00-09 太多碟冇得用streaming聽翻
好似Site Access 假音人
大家都未必咁熟或者有印象當年既indie甚至次主流既音樂

10年代初好多碟都有得用spotify聽翻
我都因為咁而識 no one remains virgin 等

放空

恭喜Kontinue!
可惜Felix 入唔到50強...

mrshadowll

00-09冇cm 愛將，大家梗係唔贊成

eggsteven

辛苦哂所有搞手！！好成功嘅一個活動
唔贊成搞00-09 大久遠 依家投番一定好多bias

kin888

I do understand what you are saying. I think 2000-2009 is worthy for these reasons:

1. It's still part of the current century, so looking back is still interesting. I am sure there will be tons of listicles in 2025 celebrating the 21st century. And many songs in those 10 years still make an impact. And many current favorites got their start in this decade, so it's relevant to the artists as well, so to speak. Appreciating history is always a big part of sustaining culture...any noise about Cantopop is probably not a bad thing for HK music industry.

2. CM awards started in 2003, so it can be done as a celebration of the longevity of this forum. 20th or 25th is a huge milestone so that could be the angle we can use, if we don't want to do in 2025.

Basically, the success of this 百大選 helps increase CM's profile. It would be a little bit of a shame if we have to wait 10 years to do it again.

cy_lee96

My January 差少少

JayantL

年代百大選今次真係搞得好成功辛苦晒
見到好多嘅歌手、平台
甚至 上面嘅同路人 or 關心留意廣東歌嘅地區 都有repost百大選
影響力大過好多唔敢發聲嘅奶共歌手

不過我就唔支持搞00-09

一嚟年代太久遠 增加一眾搞手嘅工作量同負荷
同埋20年代搞00-09好似好唔make sense

二嚟
過去嘅 就由得佢過去啦~如果連CM都走上throwback之路對香港樂壇唔係一件好事

kin888

Only 14 out of 25 for my ballot. I think I am most surprised about LMF and 撫愛. Kind of shocking that CM didn't recognize how groundbreaking and necessary 撫愛 was, especially after 在錯誤的宇宙尋找愛 was #9 for songs.

But I am glad all albums I nominated have votes, even though I couldn't find room for most of them at the end.

But once again, really thankful for this whole project. I can tell that it is a huge, huge amount of work. I listened to about 95% of the songs nominated before each 初選 and around 3 cuts per albums before voting there. So I was really introduced to a lot of good music and was reminded of so many songs that I loved before. I wished CM cared more for some artists that I love (Fama, Phil), but it is what it is.

One more push for 2000 - 2009 百大選! My correlation will probably be even worse, but the whole process would be so, so much fun.

kin888

Top 5 Companies
1. 東亞/寰亞 -- 8 (5, 6, 9, 11, 24, 29, 39, 49)
2. Universal -- 7 (4, 10, 14, 21, 25, 33, 45)
3. EEG -- 4 (21, 21, 26, 40)
4. 紅線音樂 -- 4 (8, 31, 34, 45)
5. Warner -- 4 (16, 37, 42*, 48)
*Distribute only

Top 5 Albums without 百大單曲
19. Connected -- RubberBand
19. 邪童謠 -- Serrini
21. 小日子 -- 容祖兒
21. 0 -- 林憶蓮
24. The Strength of Weakness -- 鄧小巧

Top 5 百大單曲 without corresponding eligible albums in top 50
4. 青春頌 -- 許廷鏗 (131. 長大)
7. 最後的信仰 -- 林二汶 (61. 初音)
17. 高山低谷 -- 林奕匡 (101. 3)
19. 那邊見 - Swing (/. Swing到盡)
21. 六月飛霜 - 陳奕迅 (133. Stranger Under My Skin)

小伙子.

投Much Feeling Little Thinking嘅朋友係咪好鍾意星空跳去星空（鋼琴版）嗰種好似聽緊細碟嘅感覺？{ ...
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:53

   我真係投左呢隻碟

bagfgfcde

Me
我幾鍾意呢啲噪音
weiquan 發表於 2020-5-10 23:47

呢隻真係好掂
我既年代香港碟 top 20 應該有份

可惜近年冇歌 係CM冇聲勢
如果佢地好似粉紅A咁19年突然重返樂壇可能有機

weiquan

107        A New World If You Can Take It        ANWIYCTI        2014        15.5

想知邊位會員有投呢隻咁高質既碟

原 ...
bagfgfcde 發表於 2020-5-10 23:41

Me
我幾鍾意呢啲噪音

bagfgfcde

107        A New World If You Can Take It        ANWIYCTI        2014        15.5

想知邊位會員有投呢隻咁高質既碟

原來我只係俾咗b組

on07111

今日會幾點公布？

個人估計兩個位係 CM 女王，兩個位係男歌手（其中一個可以當樂團計），一個位係天團 ...
powerful 發表於 2020-5-10 11:38

中哂

永遠是軒

咁多人投felix

616.1314

投Much Feeling Little Thinking嘅朋友係咪好鍾意星空跳去星空（鋼琴版）嗰種好似聽緊細碟嘅感覺？{ ...
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:53

雖然我同意曲目編排真係好差
但係無可否認 single collection 係一零年代嘅一個趨勢
而 Much Feeling Little Thinking 都算係一隻 GQ 嘅 single collection
呢點我覺得都值得入嘅

b01091018

有請牙jude

mosesming

喂呀
小伙子. 發表於 2020-5-10 22:50

    投Much Feeling Little Thinking嘅朋友係咪好鍾意星空跳去星空（鋼琴版）嗰種好似聽緊細碟嘅感覺？

小伙子.

投初音嘅朋友係咪好鍾意隻碟由初音跳去Yeah嗰下喜感？
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:45

喂呀

mosesming

淨係廣東碟？

For me:  
1. JTW 西遊記
2. A Tragedy Your Majesty
3. Don’t Text Him
4. 0
...
bagfgfcde 發表於 2020-5-10 22:44

係
如果加埋國語碟條equation會複雜好多
而且淨計廣東碟都見得人（去到15/16位都仲OK）
就唔計（香港歌手嘅）英文／國語碟了

mosesming

投初音嘅朋友係咪好鍾意隻碟由初音跳去Yeah嗰下喜感？

bagfgfcde

我嘅十大專輯（本身冇投）
1. Kontinue
2. 優與美
3. 飛蛾光顧
4. Matt Force
5. Don't Text Him
6. 邪童謠 ...
mosesming 發表於 2020-5-10 22:36

淨係廣東碟？

For me:
1. JTW 西遊記
2. A Tragedy Your Majesty
3. Don’t Text Him
4. 0
5. Unnatural Objects And Their Humans
6. 23:59 Before Tomorrow
7. 邪童謠
8. A Ghost and His Paintings
9. 適婚的年齡
10. Easy/Connected

on07111

Alfred都比人打壓得好慘  
希望大家都支持下
cymusic 發表於 2020-5-10 22:37

   比左1A1B.雖然A離入圍差一半分